Fiscal Drag Still Threatens the Recovery
Last week brought good news for the U.S. economy: according to the Labor Department, the headline unemployment rate fell to 8.3 percent as payrolls added 243,000 new jobs in January. That number climbs to 304,000 if you include the revised numbers for November and December, which underestimated employment by a full 60,000. And job growth was well distributed throughout the private sector, with impressive gains in professional and businesses services, leisure and hospitality, and manufacturing. “That sound you hear is champagne corks in the west wing,” tweeted Washington Post economics reporter Neil Irwin at the news.
But while it’s surely five o’clock somewhere (probably China, in this particular metaphor), champagne-soaked celebration would be premature. There are, as Ezra Klein points out, “fiscal bombs”—or perhaps more accurately a “fiscal minefield”—about to explode beneath our feet.
The problem is this: if current law holds, the payroll tax cut and expanded unemployment benefits will soon end, followed by the expiration of the Bush tax cuts and the winding down of what remains of the stimulus money. Then comes the implementation of the $1.2 trillion automatic sequester, which will take a huge bite out of Medicare and other non-defense discretionary spending. According to the CBO—which, crucially, must base its analysis solely on current law—those higher taxes and lower deficits will costs us 0.5 percent of GDP in 2012 and 1.65 percent in 2012—enough to slow economic growth to just 1 percent. The IMF agrees: they estimate such “fiscal drag” could cost the U.S. as much as 2 percent of GDP in 2012—”the largest annual fall in at least four decades.”
Decisive action from lawmakers to extend the payroll tax holiday, reinvest in infrastructure, and support state and local governments would go a long way toward preventing that fiscal drag until the economy is more solidly on its feet. As Jared Bernstein notes, the Recovery Act demonstrated just how effective state fiscal relief was for preserving local government jobs. Unfortunately, that money was temporary; now that the stimulus has run its course, we have returned to a hemorrhaging public sector, with 14,000 jobs lost just last month. Immediate action to keep police, teachers, and other state government employees on the payroll would go a long way toward avoiding “fiscal drag” and giving our local economies time to secure a meaningful recovery.
